UK 05:49 Sunday, 22 November 2026
Breaking news and expert analysis on fast-moving AIM and LSE listed shares
Logo
Menu

Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from ShareProphets). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.


TRAK

TrakM8, another lie for Paul Scott to ignore completely - the curious numbers of the Box Deal

Paul Scott has today dismissed THREE lies told by TrakM8 (TRAK) in RNS statements as irrelevant. Whatever. So let's go with a fourth and from there look at what was hailed as a transformative deal, the purchase of Box Telematics Ltd in a Reverse takeover in October 2013.

Already a member? Sign in


• All premium articles

• Tom Winnifrith’s Bearcast

• Access to all the entire nearly 13 year archive

• ShareProphets Daily Newsletter


Cancel any time

This area of the ShareProphets.com site is for independent financial commentary. These blogs are provided by independent authors via a common carrier platform and do not represent the opinions of ShareProphets.com. ShareProphets.com does not monitor, approve, endorse or exert editorial control over these articles and does not therefore accept responsibility for or make any warranties in connection with or recommend that you or any third party rely on such information. The information available at ShareProphets.com is for your general information and use and is not intended to address your particular requirements. In particular, the information does not constitute any form of advice or recommendation by ShareProphets.com and is not intended to be relied upon by users in making (or refraining from making) any investment decisions.

Comments

  1. Hi Tom,

    I fail to see what relevance any of the above has to the group’s future performance – which is what investors are backing, and on which the company is valued.

    Your favourite stock – Optibiotix – is not valued on its historic profits, is it? No, because there aren’t any! It’s a zero turnover business, burning cash, so by your rules it should be valued at nil, but it’s actually valued at £62m. Why? Because investors are valuing Optibiotix on estimates of future potential.

    TRAK is valued by investors on a multiple of broker forecasts. It’s growing very rapidly, organically mainly, from successful selling of innovative products, to recurring monthly subscribers. The current valuation of TRAK looks fine to me – it’s valued at about 17 times consensus estimates, and it has a history of out-performing against forecasts – upgrades occurred in both Jul 2015, and Nov 2015.

    Your obsessing over minor details in the past is pointless. So the worst thing you can come up with is a £115k discrepancy between £850k claimed profits, and £735k profit reported at Companies House. If I had found such an (immaterial) discrepancy, do you know what I would have done? Picked up the phone, asked to speak the the FD, and requested an explanation. I don’t know the answer, but it is common to adjust profits for acquired companies, to strip out things like owner dividends/salaries, etc. There are often adjustments made in that type of situation.

    Calling this another “lie” is, once again, completely inappropriate, and makes you look silly. If you find some minor differences in the figures, just ask for an explanation from the company.

    As for inter-company transactions – there is nothing sinister about those at all. I used to be FD for a group of companies, and there were thousands of transactions within the group each year – goods might be bought by one company in the group on behalf of another, shared overheads would be split & apportioned out within the group. It’s entirely normal to have loads of inter-company transactions within a group, so your assertion that intercompany deals are “always a bad sign” is nonsense, in my experience.

    The individual company accounts within a group don’t necessarily give you a true picture, because the group may not bother to apportion out & reinvoice overheads, etc. Some groups let the profit build up in one company, it doesn’t matter, because all the group transactions are eliminated on consolidating the accounts. So it’s the overall group accounts that you need to focus on.

    I really can’t work out what your agenda is here. It’s like you’re desperately trying to find a smoking gun, in the misguided belief that TRAK is a wrong ‘un. Trouble is, it’s not a wrong ‘un. It’s a good growth company, that’s doing well.

    Anyway, I’m getting really bored with this, so have come to the conclusion it’s a waste of time rebutting your points, as you never admit you’re wrong anyway, even when you are wrong.

    I’ll let the company answer PI questions when I interview the CEO on Monday, and we can then assess what their side of the story is, and people can make up their own minds.

    Regards, Paul.

    P.S. I’m knackered & gagging for a beer (in Dry January), hence why the above is a bit bad-tempered!! ;-)


  2. Drunken Sailor

    Paul,

    Attention to detail is important. For a company to make so many not all that important mistakes – what is a few £K difference in the true figures and the reported figures between friends after all, is a very bad sign. At best management are incompetent at worst they are deliberately misleading investors. Are there any mistakes that make things look worse than they really are? Anyone who is a bit sloppy will make mistakes that balance out and are therefore irrelevant. All we have seen so far are mistakes that always paint a rosier picture than reality. Perhaps you can show that they also make mistakes in the other direction. If you can’t then the weight of evidence is building and dismissing individual mistakes as irrelevant is holding less and less water.

    Looking forward to your report on what the CEO says on Monday. Do not let the fact that you are invested make you into a Zac Mir, be Jeremy Paxman on steroids and don’t let him duck hard questions – it is the only way to restore credibility after so many mistakes that always flatter reality.

  3. Although the pretax profits of £734,651 are shown in the accounts filled for BOX if you look at the BOX admission document (http://www.trakm8.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/RNS-9764P-Schedule-1-Admission-Document_8th-Oct-2013.pdf) its states pretax profits of £850,000 as mentioned in the RNS.

    I am no expert in accountancy but the admission document states that the accounts have been restated in IFRS as opposed to UK GAAP, which is what BOXs own accounts have been produced in accordance with. Could this be the reason for the discrepancy? If so i believe you owe trakm8 an apology for branding them liars.

  4. SiddyG

    So presumably 2014 a/c prepped by TrakM8 will show a restated 850k for 2012 for Box. Oh…they dont. The 850k number appears nowhere – just face it TrakM8 lied again

    T

  5. Its looking like 2 -0 to Beam Me up Scotty in the debate with Whinny Froth re BOO and Trackm8

    .

Complete Coverage

That Was the Week that Was 7 Days of ShareProphets

Saturday »

Bear
New Sharestock speaker announced: the Dark Destroyer is back! Book Now!
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 21 November 2026, 16:52
Boom
BREAKING: Davion Healthcare it gets worse – surely the SEC is all over this $306m scandal like a rash
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 21 November 2026, 16:51
Bearcast
Tom Winnifrith Bearcast: Kefi
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 21 November 2026, 16:01
DIS
Distil – hopefully our prior warnings were heeded…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 21 November 2026, 08:27

Friday »

ENET
Ethernity Networks – $1.36m patent licensing agreement, but still financial uncertainty?…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 20 November 2026, 15:59
Bearcast
Tom Winnifrith Bearcast No 2: Reabold suspended, everything that is wrong about AIM
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 20 November 2026, 15:36
PR1
Pri0r1ty Intelligence Group: more confetti vicar?
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 20 November 2026, 15:02
GoldfishShark
Video: ‘Massive Distortion’, Gold’s Bottom & Why The ‘Largest Upside’ is in Silver Miners
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 20 November 2026, 14:44
FADL
Fadel Partners – states “pleased to announce” recommended offer, but it’s ANOTHER AIM IPO Roll-Call of Shame…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 20 November 2026, 14:15
Bearcast
Tom Winnifrith Bearcast: a few thoughts on Skins and Opti
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 20 November 2026, 12:59
ECP
EXPOSE: Eight Capital Partners the rebuttal is more ludicrous than the original RNS
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 20 November 2026, 12:32
CML
CML Microsystems – interims, winning share tip value?
  • By HotStockRockets
  • 20 November 2026, 11:05
THRU
Thruvision – an upcoming “potential requirement” for additional funding or an actual requirement?…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 20 November 2026, 10:55

Thursday »

BTC
London Bitcoin’s dismal interim results & rapacious management greed
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 19 November 2026, 17:28
KOO
A Frosty Exchange at Mello rampfest - Kooth and the bear dossier
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 19 November 2026, 17:06
IKA
Ilika – argues “continued progress in the commercialisation”, but how materially?…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 19 November 2026, 16:00
RST
Restore plc – an “expects… to be at least in line with consensus expectations” Buy
  • By Tom Winnifrith & Steve Moore
  • 19 November 2026, 13:39
MCB
McBride – states “resilient and growing underlying demand”, But…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 19 November 2026, 13:39
QQ
QinetiQ – interims, a growth and shareholder returns Buy
  • By Tom Winnifrith & Steve Moore
  • 19 November 2026, 12:49
BMV
Bluebird Mining Ventures - the "share buy back" spoofs not working
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 19 November 2026, 12:23
Bearcast
Tom Winnifrith Bearcast: Noel emails me to say I am a f***ing c**t
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 19 November 2026, 12:03
CTA
CT Automotive – profit warning and how much confidence to really have in its argued 2027 recovery?
  • By Steve Moore
  • 19 November 2026, 10:53

Wednesday »

Bear
Blue Moon Metals: From Russia, With Love, a new bear dossier from Fraser Perring
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 18 November 2026, 16:06
MSLH
Marshalls – how “resilient” is its trading and outlook?…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 18 November 2026, 15:50
Collapsing-Reactor
Bad News travels slowly, another red flag as Nuburu warns of delayed financials for Q3 2026
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 18 November 2026, 15:44
HAS
Hays plc – emphasises profit “materially above current consensus”, but what’s already in the price?
  • By Steve Moore
  • 18 November 2026, 14:00
Bearcast
Tom Winnifrith Bearcast: I hate being lied to so much & as gold falls I ask why I keep owning Golden Prospect
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 18 November 2026, 11:16
MPAL
Dirty Dozen: the 12 most-read stories about Medpal AI
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 18 November 2026, 11:16
MPAC
Mpac – argues “encouraging” pipeline of potential opportunities, but what about pipeline conversion?…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 18 November 2026, 11:14
GPM
Will I be taking up my bonus Golden Prospect shares asks the Dinosaur?
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 18 November 2026, 08:05
GEX
Dirty Dozen: the 12 most-read stories about Georgina Energy
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 18 November 2026, 08:04
Bear
AI crash Update, post Nvidia sex scandal, 3 clear zeros to short 
  • By Lucian Miers
  • 18 November 2026, 08:03
Boom
Oak Securities – rumours of FCA enquiry doing the rounds
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 18 November 2026, 08:01

Tuesday »

PULS
Pulsar Group – after a “Capital Access Window… to make it easier to reach a broader range of investors”…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 17 November 2026, 16:05
Bearcast
Tom Winnifrith Bearcast: My supposed grievances
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 17 November 2026, 15:48
PANR
Pantheon Resources placing – a success or a failure?
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 17 November 2026, 13:51
TRI
Trifast – after last month “confident in delivering further margin improvement in H2”, what about now with its half-year results?
  • By Steve Moore
  • 17 November 2026, 13:42
AMRQ
Amaroq at 102p: could be 220p, 530p or 1000p says Citi
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 17 November 2026, 13:13
G4M
Gear4Music heading into reverse gear: do not catch the falling knife
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 17 November 2026, 12:29
FLO
Flowtech Fluidpower – after “confident in its outlook for the remainder of the year” in September, what about now a “Trading Update”?…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 17 November 2026, 11:05
EU_flag
Shocking new jobs data, Britain cannot keep going like this and the answer is not to send £750m a week to the EU
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 17 November 2026, 10:35
TERN
Tern: is it game over?
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 17 November 2026, 09:51
OPTI
Lyin’ Steve O’Hara getting really desperate in a second utterly misleading video
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 17 November 2026, 09:35

Monday »

QED
Quadrise – “pleased to announce… Valkor funds receipt”, but how significant?
  • By Steve Moore
  • 16 November 2026, 15:59
HAMA
The price of retaining a talent like Nicola Horlick
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 16 November 2026, 15:12
MEGP
ME Group International – ‘year-end trading update’ emphasises “continued growth in laundry operations”, but what about overall?…
  • By Steve Moore
  • 16 November 2026, 13:57
Bearcast
Tom Winnifrith Bearcast: Police Time wastin' Steve O'Hara and his shares, just so disingeneous
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 16 November 2026, 13:39
MPAL
Medpal AI – has Clear Capital been selling shares?
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 16 November 2026, 12:21
SWC
My NBF seems to have lost £93.5 million on bitcoin
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 16 November 2026, 11:46
SOLI
Solid State – “pleased” with first half performance, but what about the bottom-line outlook?
  • By Steve Moore
  • 16 November 2026, 11:32
GEX
Weather in Wiluna & Wrexham – a deep dive that the FCA should be all over
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 16 November 2026, 10:42
AMRQ
Canaccord upgrades stance and increases Amaroq target price
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 16 November 2026, 09:46
GEX
EXPOSE: Georgina Energy: more lies check out actual road closures in WA & do some geekish meteorology!
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 16 November 2026, 09:24

Sunday »

ECP
Letter to FRC: Marking your card on Eight Capital & Bright Graham Murray
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 15 November 2026, 18:51
ALU
A “positive trading momentum” recovery Buy
  • By HotStockRockets
  • 15 November 2026, 18:27
Bearcast
Tom Winnifrith bearcast: when does Pantheon run out of cash and why the blue wave in the US will sink it
  • By Tom Winnifrith
  • 15 November 2026, 18:22
Gold
The View From The Montana Log-Cabin As Gold Falls Again: Time To Do Precisely Nothing!
  • By Nigel Somerville
  • 15 November 2026, 09:11
Quiz
The ShareProphets Sunday Pub Quiz #372
  • By Darren Atwater
  • 15 November 2026, 08:27
Blackboard
Visual Aid: The World’s Longest Place Names, unlike yesterday New Zealand beats Wales into second
  • By Darren Atwater
  • 15 November 2026, 08:27
Reading
Sunday Long Reads: Worst Service Station, Russell Brand, Conscious AI, Bougie Bakeries, the Patron Saint Of Strippers & Stocks
  • By Darren Atwater
  • 15 November 2026, 08:25
Top-10
Notes from Underground – Most read articles for the week ending November 14
  • By Darren Atwater
  • 15 November 2026, 08:20