Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from ShareProphets). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.
I probably shouldn’t write this piece. Making personal judgement on geopolitical events inevitably results in oversimplification and, almost certainly, misunderstanding. I’ve never been to Kurdistan, so the truth is I can’t really have any real insight to what on earth is happening over there. However, my money is mine to do with as I please, and I suspect that the current pullback in Gulf Keystone (GKP) will present an excellent buying opportunity.
Already a member? Sign in
• All premium articles
• Tom Winnifrith’s Bearcast
• Access to all the entire nearly 13 year archive
• ShareProphets Daily Newsletter
Cancel any time
This area of the ShareProphets.com site is for independent financial commentary. These blogs are provided by independent authors via a common carrier platform and do not represent the opinions of ShareProphets.com. ShareProphets.com does not monitor, approve, endorse or exert editorial control over these articles and does not therefore accept responsibility for or make any warranties in connection with or recommend that you or any third party rely on such information. The information available at ShareProphets.com is for your general information and use and is not intended to address your particular requirements. In particular, the information does not constitute any form of advice or recommendation by ShareProphets.com and is not intended to be relied upon by users in making (or refraining from making) any investment decisions.
Comments
Al
Are you some military extremist expert then? worst guess assumption ever. especially with GKP being eyeballs in debt.
ADVFNPrep
Hi Ben,
I happen to have a big interest in geopolitics and I personally think the situation is rather explosive.
Kirkuk is a powder keg, with an explosive mix of Arabs and Kurds who never got along very well. I believe that Kirkuk, due to its oil industry, is the price the Islamists are after on the short term. These guys need income if they want to create an Islamic state. This has also been the strategy in Syria; capture oil fields.
It would also be foolish to deny the popular support the insurgents have among Sunni Arabs, or that they just consist of ISIL. ISIL happens to have a good propaganda machine, but the insurgents also involve Sunni Ba’athists from the Saddam-age Iraqi army and other, less radical, Islamist groups. Sunni have been marginalized by the Iraqi regime.
Additionally, the militants already have a genuine foothold in Anbar province and some other areas in Iraq. Obviously, these area’s of Iraq also border Syria where the Islamists also have a genuine foothold.
wildrides
Its not a handful of militants . Its a huge force, growing daily and spread across part of Syria and now North Iraq. They are well armed and trained and madder than a box of frogs .
However the Kurds are as hard as nails and an effective fighting force . I dont think the invasion will trouble them or invade their region . They have a reputation, well earned and I think the invaders will keep away and instead fight the battles they can win . So if your company is in the Kurds region it should be fine . Market sentiment however is another thing …… and that might not be fine !
Why take the risk ?
Ben Turney
@Al – Mindless comment. Try reading the piece. Of course, I’m not and have littered this with as many caveats as I could.
@ADVFNprep yes, but the huge wave of people who fled in advance of the militants doesn’t suggest this has been at all well received on the ground.
What I think is going to be far more explosive is how the Iraqi government responds to the occupation by Kurdish forces of Kirkuk. If the Kurds dig in there, there is obvious potential for trouble.
The lack of American reaction so far also looks telling. Irrespective of the PR of the US Army leaving Iraq, there are still tens of thousands of American soldiers in Iraq, working under the banners of “security consultants”. Syria is nowhere near as important an oil producing country as Iraq and the Americans were also content to let Assad get his comeuppance (not to mention the disruption to Russia’s strategic naval bases). In hindsight, as the situation has developed and the fundamentalists appear to have strengthened their grip, they might now regret this, but I can’t imagine they will allow events in Iraq to spiral out of control in such a way.
I haven’t read anywhere of any involvement of Ba’athist involvement in the militant occupation of Mosul. To be honest, your point there doesn’t make much sense. In Syria it is the Ba’athists who have been the primary target and I can’t see how the black flags I’ve seen in pictures from Mosul will have attracted Ba’athist sympathisers.
Please correct me if you’ve seen any coverage about this anywhere.
I wouldn’t yet buy GKP, while the situation is so volatile and in its infancy, but I am watching this very closely, as I remain convinced this is an overreaction.
Ben Turney
@wildrides, the highest number of fighters I’ve seen is 5,000. Again please point me in the direction of any other sources which claim more.
ADVFNPrep
Hi Ben,
This huge wave of people fled for various reasons. Some apparently fled because they feared government airstrikes (a.o. recent BBC article). I also do not think these insurgents can capture a 1.8 million city (Mosul) without any support from its residents.
This wave of refugees, together with tons of Syrian refugees already in Iraqi Kurdistan, will destabilize Iraqi Kurdistan.
As to Ba’athists; these are Shia in Syria and Sunni in Iraq. This is not about Ba’athism (dead in Iraq), this is sectarian. Sunni Ba’athists in Iraq support the Sunni insurgency. The Ba’athists are, by the way, mentioned in among others the NYT 4 hours ago.
I agree that the Iraqi government response will be critical as Kirkuk is also disputed between Iraqi Kurdistan and the Iraq government; obviously due to its oil wealth. Saddam tried to make the city Arab for this reason so there is a lot of bad blood.
As to Americans, I applaud their decision not to get involved. I hope they realize it is a lost cause to try to retain Sunni Iraq in Shia Iraq government control.
wildrides
I think if you had 5000 of those guys armed and parked up 100 miles or so from your place in the UK your backside would become a brick factory .
Hardly a handful ….5000
Source ITN , C4 ,BBC
etc etc . Thought to be increasing by 10 fighters per day (same source)
Not an investment I would consider in any way shape or form .
However , happy to disagree , no offence ;-) as always just banter .
trashbat
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jun/12/how-battle-ready-isis-iraqi-army-peshmerga
7,000 estimated in Iraq and Syria. 800 in Mosul alone according to similar results. Plus a lot of support from other factions.
Even if they weren’t a force to be reckoned with, noone wants to or dares buy oil from Kurdistan; for example:
https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/genel-energy-plc-gulf-keystone-103839808.html
The only potential “positive” scenario I can see is that the collapsing Iraqi state bolsters Kurdistan’s independence/autonomy and actually reduces the problems of not having Iraq’s approval. Very unlikely and something to gamble on, not invest.
wildrides
I note the Kurds have expanded their territory by recapturing from isis an oil town the Iraq government forces abandoned . Fearsome warrior tribe the kurds . Isis wont want to mess with them . If they do they will get slaughtered . Isis are only used to fighting on flat desert plains with good roads . Kurds are kings of the mountains where they live . They will never be beaten on their home turf .
Ben Turney
This is an interesting discussion, thank you to everyone who has joined in
@ADVFNprep – I think you applauded the American decision too quickly. If this uprising is serious, then I think we can expect drone operations to commence very quickly. I doubt the Americans will bother go to the UN about this.
@wildrides – absolutely no offense taken whatsoever, this is a lively discussion. To my mind 5,000 still represents a handful of fighters (or 7,000 even as trashbat suggests). It sounds like the Americans are saddling up as we speak and that will almost certainly be the deciding factor. Good point about ISIS not wanting to engage the Kurds on their home turf. I hadn’t thought so much about the terrain, but I think it strengthens my argument.
@trashbat – An independent Kurdish state in northern Iraq causes one hell of a headache for the Turks. Given the historical strategic importance of the American and Turkish relationship, I’d be very surprised if this was an outcome, but it does look like the Kurds are seizing their chance to grab land
trashbat
I agree that Kurdish statehood is probably not internationally palatable, but in practice, the Kurds are apparently able to defend themselves better than the rest of Iraq. Indeed the relatively very good security situation in Erbil has been a boost to GKP in recent times, and to an extent I’m not overly familiar with, Turkish/Kurdish relations seem to have significantly improved.
The last few years have seen wrangling over the KRG’s dues to Baghdad when exporting oil. The collapse or even mere weakening of central governance affords them either better a negotiating position or the ability to go it alone. I doubt you need to establish a full fat independent state to get workable oil exports that other nations are willing to accept.
However I say profiting from this scenario is unlikely because it’s early days in a complex geopolitical situation, and even if it does happen, it’s surely not going to be a simple one way ticket to positives. Iraq imploding is not good news overall for anyone near it, and I think you underestimate the damage that ISIS can inflict and/or what the current situation says about the fragility of the country.
I should add that I consider GKP to be such a basket case that none of these things should be used to buy in anyway.