Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from ShareProphets). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.
At about 3.30pm yesterday, Brokerman Dan revealed his exclusive scoop that Horse Hill was about to yield a commercial oil discovery. This triggered a mini-buying frenzy, which drove the share prices of the listed companies involved in Horse Hill much higher. As the most exposed Horse Hill play, UK Oil & Gas (UKOG) flew from 1.16p, to hit an intraday high of 1.7p, all within the last hour of trading! This morning, as a flurry of RNSs hit the market and the dust settled, it turned out that Dan’s figures were well off the mark. A commercial discovery hasn’t been announced (read the RNSs thoroughly for confirmation of this). Also, the current size of the discovery is “only” a preliminary estimate of 3.1million barrels of oil in place, not 15million to 20million barrels. In the ensuing sharp sell off, UK Oil & Gas is back down to 1.15p. Dan is likely to come in for criticism for his reporting of this event, but this is misguided. Here’s why.
Already a member? Sign in
• All premium articles
• Tom Winnifrith’s Bearcast
• Access to all the entire nearly 13 year archive
• ShareProphets Daily Newsletter
Cancel any time
This area of the ShareProphets.com site is for independent financial commentary. These blogs are provided by independent authors via a common carrier platform and do not represent the opinions of ShareProphets.com. ShareProphets.com does not monitor, approve, endorse or exert editorial control over these articles and does not therefore accept responsibility for or make any warranties in connection with or recommend that you or any third party rely on such information. The information available at ShareProphets.com is for your general information and use and is not intended to address your particular requirements. In particular, the information does not constitute any form of advice or recommendation by ShareProphets.com and is not intended to be relied upon by users in making (or refraining from making) any investment decisions.
Comments
John ☠ The Tax Collector ☠ Zacchaeus
30% or 40% of 3.1m is only 1 million barrels of oil. I bet the flow rates were not very good either and bet they’d be lucky to get 25 bopd. Hardly worth shouting about considering HH-1 has cost an estimated 6 million pounds already.
If the gas doesn’t come up, UKOG will be plugged and abandoned. You might think the market reaction is harsh, but UKOG is severely overvalued and shold be shorted IMO
Ben Turney
@John – I didn’t say the market reaction was harsh. I agree with James Parters’ assessment of the valuation, but this wasn’t the point of my piece
John ☠ The Tax Collector ☠ Zacchaeus
The market reaction is generous. UKOG should easily be sub 0.5p as the cost to extract that oil would ruin all the HH players. If UKOG is valued at £18m for 13% of a 1m boe well , the inevitable, like what happens to all other AIM stocks is going to happen…
Having said that, given the ludricrous UKOG vauation, I can’t imagine what with President Petroleum if they find even more oil in mid November. The oil find announced just a few days ago was frankly, incredible (250m net lay oil), yet only went up 90%! The AIM game continues to fascinate us!
Slim McFizzlebeef
Ben Turney definition of an insider – a guy ‘inside’ the company
FCA definition – anyone with any inside information as a result of:
■ having access to the information through employment or duties
■ having access to the information as a result of crime, i.e. theft
■ obtaining the information by other means, i.e. tip-off by friend
Muse
I’m not sure that he had a “duty” to publish anything. It was clearly price sensitive so he had no way of checking it against anything published, People employed or connected to these companies shouldn’t be passing on confidential information. IMO what BMD should have done was contacted the company in question and as an aside furnished them with the details of the person passing on the information.
That way a lot of people wouldn’t have lost money even though they were daft to buy on a rumour.
I defend the concept of “whistle blowers” as wrong doing should always have an avenue to be exposed but to put this tawdry trading op. in a similar context is wrong. There was no need journalistic or otherwise for him to publish the rumour other than that wanting to present a “scoop” to those traders.
What is it they say to fledgling journalist’s?Check, check and double check and if in doubt ……don’t publish.
Bigsam
What damage to the reputation did this do to bmd?Answer, nil to those who know that he is a tosser
Ben Turney
@John I agree about PPC, though I think you are overstating the current discovery. Potential is there, but a fund raising first seems more likely.
@slim – you need to add to that the definition of market abuse. I don’t believe Dan would have traded yesterday’s rumour. The insider rules relate specifically to trades made or not made by an insider.
@Muse – I think it’s clear his information came from inside one of the companies or from someone closely associated. Given the fast moving nature of these things, I stand by the comment he did the right thing publishing. As he said in his piece today, if people bought off the back of that, it is there call. In terms of the “journalistic need” to publish, as I said, he put his reputation on the line. He was obviously confident in the accuracy of what he was told, otherwise why else would he have published?
nahkit
“it is blindingly obvious he was passed them from someone with intimate knowledge of the drill”
“he was passed this information by someone who knew the real figures. Dan certainly didn’t make the figures up”.
“Anything he, or I for that matter, writes is speculation”.
Can you run that past me again please?
“Blindingly obvious he got the figures from someone in the know” but you regard his publishing this information as “speculative”?
You obviously have a different interpretation of the word “speculative”.
Ben Turney
@nahkit – you’ve missed my point.
His publication of the figures must have been speculative as they were wrong.
Had he seen written evidence he surely wouldn’t have made the erroneous claim he did.
However, his figures weren’t so wrong that they look like a guess, plucked out of thin air. In very loose terms he was right, suggesting someone verbally passed him figures
Striebs
I’m 10% down on my top-up of Magellan .
If the triassic gas play dusts , what do people think the chances are of another exploration well to test the undiscovered 16mm bbl ?
Presumably it can’t be reached by a side track .
Striebs
The antics on of D.L. on twitter and this latest leak have hardly enhanced the reputation of UK onshore operators .
It wouldn’t surprise me if the industry as a whole suffers for this .
More than ever we need that triassic gas play to come in to purge the memory of the recent embarrassment .
Slim McFizzlebeef
UK’s Dallas, the next Wytch Farm, hundreds
of millions of barrels. worth up to £2 billion.
then delivered maybe 0.9m recoverable
Lenigas’ ‘we’ve done 3D seismic’ tweet.
then deleting his twitter page
BMDs ‘It’s an oil strike… and it’s commercial’.
the day before flop results.
‘ESSO drilled wrong side of the fault’.
then came in broadly same as ESSO’s log
The most BS ever seen from a UK well.