Disclosure: I have no positions in any stocks mentioned, and no plans to initiate any positions within the next 72 hours. I wrote this article myself, and it expresses my own opinions. I am not receiving compensation for it (other than from ShareProphets). I have no business relationship with any company whose stock is mentioned in this article.
Another day, another smokescreen from UK Oil & Gas (UKOG). As with all of this month’s announcements from the company, what it hasn’t said is more important than what it has. Quite how long UK Oil & Gas’ Nomad, WH Ireland, will allow the excessive over-promotion of Horse Hill to go unfettered is anyone’s guess, but in the meantime here’s what the spinners hope you are too stupid to figure out for yourself.
Already a member? Sign in
• All premium articles
• Tom Winnifrith’s Bearcast
• Access to all the entire nearly 13 year archive
• ShareProphets Daily Newsletter
Cancel any time
This area of the ShareProphets.com site is for independent financial commentary. These blogs are provided by independent authors via a common carrier platform and do not represent the opinions of ShareProphets.com. ShareProphets.com does not monitor, approve, endorse or exert editorial control over these articles and does not therefore accept responsibility for or make any warranties in connection with or recommend that you or any third party rely on such information. The information available at ShareProphets.com is for your general information and use and is not intended to address your particular requirements. In particular, the information does not constitute any form of advice or recommendation by ShareProphets.com and is not intended to be relied upon by users in making (or refraining from making) any investment decisions.
Comments
WowSoObjective
“However, for a moment, let’s assume that this year’s planned flow test of the HH-1 discovery is a success and there are 3.1million barrels of commercial oil. Thanks to the complicated ownership of Horse Hill Developments, this will mean that UK Oil & Gas can claim just over 600,000 barrels of oil in its reserves. This will do nothing to support the wildly optimistic claims made in the “independent” Nutech report, it will do nothing to support UK Oil & Gas’ market cap and the chances are it will do very little, if anything, to improve the company’s cash position.”
You talk about Horse Hill RNS giving misleading information and then you do the same. You ignore completely the RNS from 17 December 2014 in your analysis where they clearly show there was a good improvement in October figures for the Portland:
HH-1 and CF-1 Low (P90) Medium (P50) High (P10)
Structure
Discovered OIIP,mmbbls 5.7 8.2 12.1
David Lenigas may have his own agenda but he is not the only one it seems…
Ben Turney
@WowsoObjective – Fair point, I will change the figures, but my point still stands. The fact is this is still an untested discovery and calculated estimates are precisely that – estimates.
Do you disagree about the irrelevance of the flow test, the mounting costs and likelihood of fracking?
WowSoObjective
No I don’t disagree with your view. I guess I overreacted as I can’t stop seeing articles ramping and deramping HH stocks showing some bits of information and changing some others for their own benefit.
You changed the figures so I’m sorry for the previous comment, you have my apologies.
AB
Take 8.2mmbbls oil in place, the medium estimate of OOIP. HHDL has 40%: so 3.28mmbbls. UKOG has 30% of that: so 0.984mmbbls. So what shall we say for recoverability? 15%? 20%? It’s rumoured to be tight: so 0.15 to 0.2 million barrels. Nobody’s going to get-rich-quick on that. Though they might on the share price. If the net selling price of oil is $50bbl, that is revenues of $7.5-10m. Not per year – but over the whole production period. And profits of considerably less. What’s that market cap again?
Steve
Ben,
This part is also incorrect
“For a moment, let’s assume that this year’s planned flow test of the HH-1 discovery is a success and there are 8.2million barrels of commercial oil. Thanks to the complicated ownership of Horse Hill Developments, this will mean that UK Oil & Gas can claim just over 1.6million barrels of oil in its reserves.”
The 8.2 million is oil in place. The flow test will establish whether it is commercial and will form part of the assessment on recovery rates – a generous assumption would be 30% so any reserves will be less than 0.5million to UKOG.
However, I also see that you are failing to differentiate the different reservoirs and so the associated development type and costs.
The Upper Portland is a conventional reservoir that was intersected in HH-1 and it is being produced all over the Weald. The one Horse Hill has is decent should flow ok and is likely to be commercial. It is also very shallow so a re-entry and flow test and then commercial development is not going to be expensive.
The Lower Portland is also conventional – at the HH-1 location it was not oil bearing but the prognosis is that the other side of the fault could be oil bearing. Without going over the RNS’s, from memory it was mean 16.1MMBO in place. This is also shallow would require an additional well and test that again would not be too expensive – this obviously carries additional risk to the upper portland of whether there is actually oil there. It is prognosed, not proved.
Both these are conventional, already producing in the Weald, shallow and so reletaivelzy inexpensive. Subject to commerciality I see no reason for these not to get produced.
I’m not going to try and put a valuation them and I’m not invested in a horse hill stock but if the lower portland is as prognosed this is a very decent onshore prospect that can probably be developed for UKOG at least from existing resources and then possibly cashflow. I see every optimism that a production licence can be issued for the block for the upper Portland.
The lower zones, like the Kimmeridge are a different kettle of fish – whether or not oil could technically be produced from a conventional vertical well is debatable but I doubt it would be very economic – it is almost certain to need horizontal wells with the fracturing which are indeed very expensive and against which there will be much more political resistance.
I don’t believe the companies will go near this for years – as long as the production licence is secured there is no need. In fact the companies should be looking at these as acreage plays much the same as they are in the states or also the shale gas potential licences in the UK. Larger companies with deeper pockets and more patience for dealing with the political may well be interested in being involved in this – horizontal technologies advance pretty clear reducing the number wells needed to exploit these resources.
There companies have undoubtedly made a rod for their own back with over promotion and to re/iterate I don’t see value. However I think in the rush to, rightly, condemn the way it was publicised, I think it is being overlooked that this well was fairly significant in the conventional upper portland and potentially significant for what is indicated in the Kimmeridge.
Ben Turney
@AB and Steve – Thank you, but if I started 2nd guessing at recovery rates I’d draw howls of complaint and gnashing of teeth. My point is exaggerated to emphasise the point. You are right, though, it is excessively generous
Ben Turney
@WowSoObjective – Thank you
@Steve – I also have to pick you up on a point you’ve made. When you say “not expensive”, can you please quantify what you mean by “not expensive”. I think the budget for HH-1 was c.£7million. The listed companies each paid £300,000 for 5%, pro-rated and we know from Regency’s sale to Alba that there was an additional £60,000 cash call per 5%.
Gary Newman
Also we need to consider the sort of production rates that can be achieved – it is all very well focussing on reserves but a lot of it comes down to how quickly they can be extracted and what the life of the field is. If extraction rates are low then then this significantly impacts the value of future cash flows if they are a long way in the future – especially when considering return on capital employed (if for instance it takes you years to get your money back then obviously it isn’t that good an investment!).
I also note that some on the forums have been getting excited about future flow tests when my reading of the situation is that the current planning permission would only cover the Portland sands, given that a horizontal well would need to be drilled through the Kimmeridge sands in order to target as many natural fractures as possible to give it as high a chance as possible of flowing naturally (I’m still not convinced flows will justify the expense given the depth it is at etc).
Compared to other UK onshore companies that are actually producing and have been for years, the market cap of £50 million or so looks excessive to me to say the least!
Ben Turney
@Gary – that is another good point. One of the problems with writing about all that is wrong with Horse Hill in relation to the hype is a single article could easily run to thousands of words.
alcira16247
Ben
Another great piece of analytical journalism – a hallmark of the continued excellency of ShareProphets and its journalistic standards!
Having cut my holdings to zero in numerous speculative oil holdings – generally bad for your wealth, I have no interest in UKOG, other than that of an interested member of the investing community.
However, could we perhaps all agree, that as the politicians argue on how to distribute an ever smaller piece of cake, it would be a fantastic piece of good fortune for UK PLC, if the Horse Hill project actually fulfilled its most optimistic forecasts?
Also, may I respectfully say, how fed up I am at the continued sniping and criticism of David Lenigas! As far as I’m concerned this country and many thousands of investors would be a damned sight poorer without the entrepreneurial skills of Mr Lenigas.
There are plenty of folk far more deserving of critical comment running Aim companies than Mr Lenigas.
Mr Lenigas is one of the good guys! He’s actually good for your wealth! Enough said!